New FCA regulations have come into force on Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL). BNPL, also known as Deferred Payment Credit (DPC) schemes, had not previously been subject to FCA regulation, a situation which the government described as a ‘wild west’.
This new regulation means that consumers choosing BNPL products will be required to pass affordability checks before being offered credit.
As we highlighted in our February report ‘Buy Now Pay Later: A review of the markets, risks and trends’, BNPL is more of a symptom of low financial resilience than a cause of it. Our research found that while new safeguards are essential, they could come with major trade-offs that will directly impact the borrowers who need flexible credit the most.
As Fair4All Finance CEO Kate Pender explains below, while this regulation is welcome, there is a concern that over cautious regulation may remove consumers from the market at a rate disproportionate to the harm being caused. In effect, there is potential that the regulation could cause harm to the consumer groups which it is trying to protect.
‘New Buy Now Pay Later regulation could create a credit cliff-edge for up to 30% of current BNPL users. While regulation is clearly needed and welcomed, our recent research found that nearly half of those likely to be rejected have not missed a BNPL payment, so there’s a real risk that many people who currently use BNPL responsibly could be unfairly excluded. The need for credit doesn’t just disappear when you can’t access it and people are often pushed towards more expensive or unregulated alternatives, including high-cost credit or illegal money lenders.
Regulation should be the first step, not the finish line. As an industry we need to explore new ways of lending and opening up credit for people that need it most, where it’s affordable and appropriate. Millions of people’s credit needs can often be small, just a few hundred pounds. The option to borrow these small sums of money can make a huge difference – helping people manage unexpected costs and build their financial resilience.
However, there’s a £2bn supply gap in the market for this type of lending. Our recently launched Small Sum Lending pilot, in partnership with Monzo, is aiming to help fill that gap by making small amounts of affordable credit accessible to more people. And there’s more the wider banking industry can do to increase access to affordable credit
BNPL isn’t the main driver of financial distress; it’s a symptom. Treating all small sum credit as ‘high risk’ is a mistake. It leaves an untapped market to the least affordable lenders, just when people need safe credit most. Open banking and AI enabled lending can make a massive difference to understanding risk better and pricing more accurately.’
Kate Pender, CEO, Fair4All Finance
See coverage in:
BBC News Buy Now Pay Later rules to bring refunds and rejectionsCity AM A £3bn reckoning that will reshape buy now, pay later
The Financial Times ‘Buy now, pay later’ rules could exclude millions, warn consumer groups
The Guardian What do new ‘buy now, pay later’ protections mean for you?
The Huffington Post What Do The New ‘Buy Now, Pay Later’ Rules Actually Mean For You?
The Sun CREDIT CRUNCH Major changes to Buy Now Pay come into force today – what it means for you


