Fair4All Finance has responded to the FCA’s consultation on reviewing the financial promotion rules for consumer credit.
The consultation proposes simplifying parts of CONC 3, the FCA’s rules on consumer credit financial promotions, and considers how cost of credit information, including APR, could be improved to support better consumer understanding.
Simplification of CONC 3
We broadly support the FCA’s objective of simplifying rules that are outdated, duplicative or can be more effectively delivered through the Consumer Duty.
However, the Consumer Duty should not be treated as a complete substitute for all specificity. Some rules, triggers and examples help firms understand what good practice looks like in real situations, particularly where consumers have lower financial resilience, restricted access to credit, lower confidence navigating financial products, or characteristics of vulnerability.
Where detailed provisions are removed, we think the FCA should make clear that expectations have not been lowered and should preserve important examples of consumer harm through guidance, supervisory messaging, or good and poor practice publications. This is particularly important for smaller firms, community lenders and social lenders with more limited legal, regulatory or compliance capacity.
APR and the cost of credit
We welcome the FCA’s review of APR and the opportunity to comment on this important topic. For short-term, small-sum credit, APR can behave counterintuitively and make products appear disproportionately expensive, even where the actual pounds-and-pence cost is lower than a longer-term alternative.
Research from Plain Numbers and ClearScore suggests that current disclosure requirements are not working well enough for consumers. In their trial, only 13% of participants understood the current APR and Representative example disclosure well enough to answer at least 4 out of 5 comprehension questions correctly.
This matters for consumer understanding, comparison, and market supply. If people cannot understand what credit will cost in practice, they are less able to compare products, understand repayment trade-offs or make informed choices. At the same time, high headline APRs can make responsible short-term credit appear poor value or reputationally risky, affecting investor appetite and making it harder for responsible lenders to secure affordable capital and scale provision.
This matters because scaling affordable credit in the UK will require a broader and more diverse pool of capital. If high APR figures deter investment, responsible lenders may face higher funding costs, which can feed through into higher credit costs for borrowers and limit the growth of alternatives to unsuitable or unregulated credit.
We therefore suggest that the FCA should explore simpler, standardised alternatives to the current disclosure regime, rather than simply adding more information alongside Representative APR or Representative examples. Total cost of credit and a cost-per-£100 breakdown appear promising because they could help consumers understand what they will pay in pounds-and-pence terms and compare products more effectively.
Any new regime should be standardised. Different firms using different cost metrics would make comparison harder, not easier. The FCA should also avoid replacing one complex regime with another by requiring a long list of mandatory metrics that risk overwhelming consumers.
We encourage the FCA to move at pace in testing alternative disclosures, including with non-bank lenders and community finance providers. Early testing could support investor engagement and help create the conditions needed to scale responsible affordable credit within the first two years of the Financial Inclusion Strategy.
You can read our full consultation response here.


